Pin SheetUS golf field guide

Culture

Golfers and their superstitions: are they true, or are they just lucky?

Tiger Woods walks to the first tee on a Sunday in a red shirt. Jack Nicklaus is said to have carried three pennies in his pocket when he played. Golfers are rational people who track carry distances to the yard, and many of them still will not say the word shank out loud on a course. Golf may be the most superstitious of the individual sports.

Why golf breeds superstitions

Golf leaves a player alone with a lot of time to think. A round lasts four hours, but the swings add up to a couple of minutes; the rest is walking, waiting and wondering. Small details fill that space. When a good round happens while wearing a particular shirt or using a particular ball, the mind connects the two, even when nothing connects them.

People do the same thing everywhere chance is involved. Gamblers follow lucky numbers in roulette on a wheel that has no memory, and baseball players refuse to step on the foul line. A golfer has the advantage that part of the outcome really is in their hands, which makes it harder to tell where the skill ends and the ritual begins.

The superstitions golfers keep

Some rituals are personal, and some are shared across the game:

Pre-shot routines look like superstition but are not quite the same thing. A routine (a waggle, two practice swings, a look at the target) is something coaches teach, because doing the same thing before every shot steadies the nerves. A superstition is a routine that has picked up a story.

Are they true or just lucky?

The best-known test comes from a 2010 study by Lysann Damisch and colleagues at the University of Cologne. Golfers were handed a ball, and half of them were told it had turned out to be lucky for previous players. That group holed noticeably more of their ten putts. The explanation offered was confidence: believing in luck made people more sure of themselves, and more sure players perform better.

Later research was less kind. When other psychologists tried to repeat the experiment with more people, the effect mostly disappeared. The current reading is that superstitions do not change luck, and any boost they give through confidence is small. It works in the same way as the placebo effect: the belief does something, but not what the believer thinks.

Not everyone bothers. Plenty of great players have talked about practice and preparation and very little about luck, and many tour professionals today work with sports psychologists who prefer routines to rituals. The difference matters when things go wrong. A routine travels everywhere, while a lucky marker can be left in the hotel.

When a ritual turns into a problem

A superstition helps while it calms you and hurts as soon as it starts making decisions. A golfer who cannot play well without a specific ball, a specific shirt or a specific sequence of events has handed their confidence to something they cannot control. Sports psychologists see it most in players who keep adding rituals after bad rounds, until the list is longer than the swing thought.

The sensible version is to keep the harmless ones and stop before they multiply. Mark the ball with the lucky coin, by all means, but trust the clubs in the bag, and the gear page has more to say about which golf equipment is worth trusting. Nobody has yet proved the red shirt does nothing, and with 15 majors to his name, Tiger is unlikely to change now.

Questions golfers ask

Why does Tiger Woods wear red on Sundays?

His mother, Kultida Woods, believed red was his power color, and he has worn a red shirt in final rounds since his junior and college days. It became one of the best-known rituals in sport.

Do lucky charms really improve putting?

One well-known 2010 study found that golfers told they had a lucky ball made more putts. Later attempts to repeat the experiment found little or no effect, so the honest answer is that any benefit is small and comes from confidence, not luck.

What is the most common superstition in golf?

Probably not mentioning a good round while it is still going. Close behind are lucky ball markers and coins, and refusing to say the word shank on the course.